Back to Key Provisions

Cross-Border Data Transfer

Analysis of the DPDPA's approach to cross-border personal data transfers - the negative list mechanism, comparison with GDPR, and practical implications.

8 min read

Reviewed by the Data Protection team, Lakshmikumaran and SridharanLast reviewed

The DPDPA's Approach to Cross-Border Transfers

Section 16 of the DPDPA adopts a "negative list" approach to cross-border data transfers i.e., personal data may be transferred to any country or territory that has not been specifically restricted by the Central Government through notification. This is fundamentally different from the GDPR's "positive list" (adequacy) approach, where transfers are restricted by default and permitted only to countries deemed adequate or through specific transfer mechanisms. The DPDPA presumes permissibility and restricts only where necessary.

The Negative List Mechanism

Under Section 16(1), the Central Government may, by notification, restrict the transfer of personal data to specific countries or territories outside India. Until such notifications are issued, transfers are permitted to all jurisdictions. As of the current date, no countries have been placed on the restricted list. This means cross-border transfers are currently unrestricted under the DPDPA, though this could change as the Government exercises its powers when the provision becomes operational.

Practical Implications for Organisations

The current permissive regime means organisations can continue cross-border data flows without specific transfer mechanisms. However, prudent compliance requires: 1. Monitoring government notifications for any new restrictions 2. Maintaining contractual safeguards with overseas processors 3. Ensuring the Data Fiduciary's obligations (security, breach notification, erasure) extend to overseas processing 4. Documenting cross-border transfer decisions as part of accountability. Organisations should not assume the current permissive regime will continue indefinitely. Building contractual protections now provides resilience against future restrictions.

Comparison with GDPR Transfer Mechanisms

The GDPR provides multiple transfer mechanisms: • Adequacy decisions (Article 45) • Standard Contractual Clauses (Article 46(2)(c)) • Binding Corporate Rules (Article 47) • Derogations for specific situations (Article 49) The DPDPA's approach is simpler but less granular. While the DPDPA does not mandate SCCs, BCRs, or formal adequacy assessments, Section 8(2) of the DPDPA read with Rule 6(1)(f) of DPDP Rules require every Data Fiduciary to ensure that the Data Processor (even those abroad) provides the same level of protection to prevent personal data breach by implementing reasonable security safeguards as prescribed under the DPDPA. In addition, Section 16(2) of the DPDPA clarifies that other Indian laws (e.g., RBI/SEBI localisation requirements) that provides a higher degree of protection or restriction on transfer of personal data outside India are not restricted or overridden by the DPDPA. For organisations subject to both GDPR and DPDPA, maintaining GDPR-compliant transfer mechanisms will satisfy the more relaxed DPDPA requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Disclaimer: The information on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or solicitation.