Back to Key Provisions

Penalties and Consequences

Detailed breakdown of the DPDPA's penalty framework - penalty amounts, determination factors, adjudication process, and comparison with global frameworks.

10 min read

Reviewed by the Data Protection team, Lakshmikumaran and SridharanLast reviewed

Civil Penalty Framework

The DPDPA adopts an exclusively civil penalty regime, i.e., there is no criminal liability for contraventions under the DPDPA. This is a deliberate departure from the earlier Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, which included criminal sanctions, and reflects a policy choice to encourage compliance through financial deterrents rather than criminalisation. The Schedule to the Act prescribes maximum penalty amounts for different categories of violations, with the Data Protection Board having the discretion in determining the actual quantum.

Penalty Schedule

The DPDPA prescribes the following maximum penalties: 1. Failure to take reasonable security safeguards (Section 8(5)): Up to Rs 250 crore 2. Failure to notify the Board and Data Principals of a breach (Section 8(6)): Up to Rs 200 crore 3. Breach of obligations relating to children's data (Section 9): Up to Rs 200 crore 4. Breach of additional obligations by Significant Data Fiduciaries (Section 10): Up to Rs 150 crore 5. Breach of duties by a Data Principal (Section 15): Up to Rs 10,000 6. Breach of a voluntary undertaking accepted under Section 32: Up to the extent applicable, as determined by the Board 7. Non-compliance with any other provision of the Act: Up to Rs 50 crore These are maximum amounts - the Board has discretion to impose lower penalties based on the circumstances of each case. The Rs 250 crore maximum penalty for security failures signals the DPDPA's emphasis on preventive security measures.

Factors in Penalty Determination

The Board considers multiple factors when determining the quantum of penalty: • Nature, gravity, and duration of the breach • Type and nature of personal data affected • Repetitive nature of the breach (repeat offenders face higher penalties) • Whether the person made any gain or avoided any loss as a result of the breach • Whether the person took any action to mitigate the effects of the breach • Whether the monetary penalty proposed to be imposed is proportionate • the likely impact of the imposition of the penalty on the person.

Absence of Criminal Liability

The DPDPA deliberately excludes criminal sanctions, a significant policy decision. The rationale includes: • Encouraging compliance through proportionate civil penalties rather than fear of prosecution • Avoiding the chilling effect of criminal liability on innovation and data-driven businesses • Aligning with the evolving global trend toward civil enforcement in data protection However, criminal liability for data-related offences may still arise under other laws, including the IT Act (Section 72A) and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) provisions on fraud, cheating, and identity theft. Note: Section 43A of the IT Act has been omitted by Section 44 (2) (a) of the DPDPA.

Cumulative Penalties

A single incident may trigger multiple penalty provisions. For example, a single data breach may attract 1. Penalty for failure to implement reasonable security safeguards (up to Rs 250 crore) 2. Penalty for failure to notify the Board and Data Principals (up to Rs 200 crore) 3. If personal data of children were involved and additional safeguards were not taken by the Data Fiduciary, an additional penalty (up to Rs 200 crore). This cumulative potential creates a strong economic incentive for compliance.

Comparison with Global Penalties

The DPDPA's penalties are significant but differ in structure from other frameworks: • GDPR: Up to EUR 20 million or 4% of global annual turnover (whichever is higher) • DPDPA: Fixed maximum amounts (up to Rs 250 crore, approximately EUR 28 million) • CCPA: $2,663 per unintentional violation, $7,988 per intentional violation (effective as of 01 January 2025, the monetary thresholds are adjusted every odd-numbered year to reflect increases in the Consumer Price Index). The DPDPA does not link penalties to revenue, meaning the same maximum applies to both a small startup and a large multinational.

Frequently Asked Questions

Disclaimer: The information on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or solicitation.